From the Guy-To-Guy's Creed: You Can't Break What's Already Broken

Dec. 9, 2014
Queensland is a huge and relatively sparsely populated state. A broken down grader is stuck in the middle of nowhere. Nearest town 200 miles away. And they get one delivery a week. On a Friday. And today's Saturday. This is just the sort of mission you want your #1 Go-To-Guy on...

John Spathonis is an engineering manager with the Department of Transport and Main Roads, Queensland, Australia. He sent me this story about a Go-To-Guy, who influenced his career when he was a still wet-behind-the-ears apprentice:

"George was a diesel mechanic and a very smart man. It was a shame but he was also deeply troubled as a result of the Vietnam War. Anyway, George was sent to do some emergency field repairs to a road grader that had broken down. It was important that the grader be put back into service as soon as possible. It eventuated that the cast iron casing of the power steering pump had cracked completely through on one side. I think the pump was external gear type. Please forgive my memory because this was about 30 years ago.

With the main pressure housing cracked most mechanics would have given up, as a replacement pump was the only solution. But George was not your average mechanic. To keep the grader running for a few days, George did a quick fix. He skew drilled a hole in the housing across the crack and installed a bolt to hold the crack tightly together. To my admiration this worked (possibly lost a few drips of oil) and the grader was able to be used until a new pump was available. The lesson I learnt and have applied in my life ever since, is you cannot break something that is already broken. So give it a go."

For those unfamiliar, Queensland is a huge and relatively sparsely populated state--especially 30 years ago. The broken down grader that George had to deal with was probably stuck in the middle of nowhere. Nearest town 200 miles away. And they get one delivery a week. On a Friday. And today's Saturday. This is just the sort of mission you want your #1 Go-To-Guy on: "With the main pressure housing cracked most diesel mechanics would have given up..."

But not George. He knew there was nothing to lose: the pump was already broken. So he dared the skew-drill and bolt fix -- and won. Do you think George ever got laid off when the order came from above to reduce the head count? Nope. Like most Guy-To-Guys, I'd say George had a job with Main Roads for as long as he wanted it. And through his own 'can-do' example, spawned many other Go-To-Guys within. Including I suspect, John who sent me this story.

Bottom line: not attempting a band-aid fix on something that's already broken can be a mistake (within reason of course!). To discover six other costly mistakes you want to be sure to avoid with your hydraulic equipment, get "Six Costly Mistakes Most Hydraulics Users Make... And How You Can Avoid Them!" available for FREE download here.

About the Author

Brendan Casey Blog | Author

Brendan Casey is a war-weary and battle-scarred veteran of the hydraulics industry. He's the author of The Hydraulic Troubleshooting Handbook, Insider Secrets to Hydraulics, Preventing Hydraulic Failures, The Definitive Guide to Hydraulic Troubleshooting, The Hydraulic Breakdown Prevention Blueprint and co-author of Hydraulics Made Easy and Advanced Hydraulic Control. And when he's not writing about hydraulics or teaching it, Brendan is flat-out helping consulting clients from a diverse range of industries solve their hydraulic problems. To contact him visit his company's Website:
www.HydraulicSupermarket.com

Continue Reading

Motor leakage variations

Oct. 18, 2006
affect low-speed performance

The Impacts of Electrification on Fluid Power Systems

May 15, 2023
Electrification presents challenges as well as opportunities to re-evaluate and improve upon the design of hydraulics and pneumatics.

Sponsored Recommendations

7 Key Considerations for Selecting a Medical Pump

Feb. 6, 2024
Newcomers to medical device design may think pressure and flow rate are sufficient parameters whenselecting a pump. While this may be true in some industrial applications, medical...

How Variable Volume Pumps Work

Feb. 6, 2024
Variable volume pumps, also known as precision dispense pumps, are a positive displacement pump that operates by retracting a piston to aspirate a fluid and then extending the...

What is a Check Valve and How Does it Work?

Feb. 6, 2024
Acheck valve, a non-return or one-way valve, is a mechanical device that allows a gas or liquid to flow freely in one direction while preventing reverse flow in the opposite ...

The Difference Between Calibrated Orifices and Holes

Feb. 6, 2024
Engineers tasked with managing fluid flow talk about both holes and calibrated orifices, but they are two distinct entities. A hole can be any opening, but a calibrated orifice...